Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Proposed Power Plant
  • Issues from an Adamstown Resident
  • Don James


  • www.Adamstown.us
2
Contents
  • Adamstown Regional Plan
  • Benefits to Sempra/Catoctin
  • Creation of www.adamstown.us
  • Environmental
  • Safety
  • Quality of Life
  • Benefits to Adamstown?
  • Summary
3
Adamstown Regional Plan
  • Plan from 2001 – Ordinance 01-26
    • Keeps GI Zoning yet acknowledges residential growth
    • Placed development restrictions on Wade property to maintain goals of plan
    • Goal III – Provide Quality Living Environment


  • Latest Developments
    • New 700 home development in approval process for Adamstown Region
4
Benefits to Sempra/Catoctin
  • Exiting Power Line
  • Existing Zoning
  • Close to Natural Gas supply
  • Access to Treated Water supply
    • Now that the county is already moving ahead with the re-alignment of supply and discharge pipelines….

5
Creation of www.adamstown.us
  • Notice of CPCN filing
  • Sempra’s web site provided only out-dated – one sided information
    • Had not been updated since 2002
    • PS:  Still only minimal new information
  • No forum available for dissemination of opinion or free flow of information
  • No central point for information gathering
6
Creation of www.Adamstown.us …
  • Information and links to additional information
  • Questions, comments
  • Uncensored mailing list (open to anyone) for the dissemination of opinions, comments, questions


  • Long term vision is to use it for many purposes beyond the power plant – local events, organizations, etc
7
Environmental
  • CPCN application states plant will be a major facility for
    • Emissions of nitrous oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and PM10 under PSD regulations
    • NOx and volatile organic compounds (VOC) under nonattainment regulations
    • Also possible that the emissions increase of sulfur dioxide (SO2) will be in excess of the EPA’s significant emission rates
8
Environmental …
  • It states that they plan to purchase offsets to help deal with the emissions
    • How does that make the air cleaner in Adamstown?
  • From Scorecard.org
    • Eastalco already in the top 10% of the dirtiest facilities in the country
    • Frederick already in the top 10% of the dirtiest counties in the country
9
Environmental …
  • EPA officially included Frederick in the ‘nonattainment’ category for Ozone
    • We must come up with a plan by 2007
  • Water
    • supply concerns
    • discharge pollutants
10
Safety
  • Explosions
    • This plant is gas fueled. Gas can explode.
    • What happens if there is an explosion?
    • What about the chemicals stored there?
    • What about secondary explosions / chemicals stored at Eastalco?
    • How far away will the shock wave be dangerous?
      • Carroll Manor Elementary is 1 ¼ mile from the plant with nothing in between.
    • It was nice to see that there will be no on-site gas storage
  • Has an explosion Risk Assessment been conducted?
11
Safety …
  • Our Children will spend 24 hours a day less than 2 miles from the plant being subjected to the additional pollutants
    • Their bodies and minds are still developing
    • Clean air is preferred
  • The EPA developed the clear air regulations for a reason.  To protect us.
    • Purchasing offsets does not protect Adamstown
  • Construction Phase
    • No major impacts
12
Quality of Life
  • Goal III – Provide a Quality Living Environment for all
    • How do you do this by allowing the introduction of new noise – especially the unplanned steam blows?
    • How do you do this by allowing the introduction of a new source of pollutants that is significant enough to require an additional EPA and regulatory reviews, and the purchase of offsets?
13
Quality of Life …
  • Loss of Home Value
    • No one wants to purchase a home that is so close to a power plant
    • No one wants their children in a school with a nice view of the power plant
    • When the current housing boom ends, people will not want to move to Adamstown
  • Noise – especially steam
  • Lights at night (the plans call for various mitigation strategies for this)
  • Visual effect to the landscape
14
Benefits to Adamstown?
  • Absolutely none that I can see.


  • Will it lower my electricity costs – No


  • Will it expand my community facilities – No
    • Adamstown / Southern Frederick County is in need of a lot of improvements
      • New Firehouse and equipment
      • Additional recreational facilities – ball fields, large regional swimming pool, etc
      • Road improvements
15
Summary
  • Is it good for Sempra/Catoctin and Eastalco -- Without a doubt


  • Is it good for Maryland – Possibly


  • Is it safe for Adamstown residents and GOOD for Adamstown??


    • I have yet to be convinced